TN Paddling Leaders Ask TWRA to Change Trotline Regulation for Safety

Andrea White, ACA Tennessee State Director, Director of Marketing for NOLI • October 29, 2021
The tennessee fish and wildlife commission meeting is taking place on october 22 , 2021.

On October 22, 2021, I made a pilgrimage to West Tennessee to offer public comment in front of the Tennessee Fish & Wildlife Commission about Tennessee's trotline regulations. I was not alone. Daniel Rogers, the President of the West Tennessee Canoe & Kayak Club, who is both a lifelong angler and a certified ACA River Kayaking instructor, and Scott Fisher joined me.


The Tennessee Fish & Wildlife Commission (TFWC) basically serves as the Board of Directors for the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency (TWRA). On this day they were voting on the 2022 fishing regulations in preparation to print the new Fishing Guide in November. For any motion before Commission there is always a period when the Chairman solicits public comment from the gallery, which is when we expected to speak. Paddling leaders made a very conscious effort to approach the Commission as safety-minded advocates for our paddlers and our rivers with an expectation that while the Commissioners might have a different perspective, they would also be approaching the issue as responsibly minded sportsmen concerned about public safety.


TWRA Executive Director Bobby Wilson and Fish & Wildlife Commission Chairman Jim Ripley were very gracious to us and gave us time on the agenda to speak for 3-5 minutes each, but the Chairman did not allow us to speak before they voted on the fishing regulations. Bypassing the standard comment period for the fishing regulations, the Chairman took the vote, which passed unanimously, without allowing comment on the regulations before that vote was taken.


As a lifelong angler, Daniel led us off with an appeal to recognize the overlap between the paddling and fishing communities, the shared values around conservation and safety, and looking for ways our communities can work together to resolve user group conflicts. He also asked them to consider ways that the Tennessee trotline falls short of the regulations employed by neighboring states on several aspects related to safety.


Scott followed up with an appeal from the heart. He asked the Commissioners to envision kids on inner tubes floating down the river and what might have happened if a seven year old girl on an inner tube had gotten caught on that trotline instead of a professional first responder. He appealed to them to answer this call to change the regulation before there is another fatality recorded in Tennessee that is attributed to entanglement with a trotline. (Note: Brandon Archer drowned on the Buffalo River in Lobelville, TN in 2019 when his foot got caught in a trotline https://www.actionnews5.com/2019/09/03/memphis-man-drowns-river-middle-tenn/ )


I closed out the paddlers' testimony, reminding the Commissioners of all of the bridges we have crossed between TWRA and the paddling community over the last several years and continuing to hold the door open for more of those opportunities. I appealed for their consideration that we need a channel to steer user group conflicts to de-escalate conflicts and find common ground solutions before situations escalate to the point of criminal charges or fatalities. In this moment, I asked them to take a first step by focusing on all the ways the current Tennessee trotline regulation -- as amended by the Fish & Wildlife Commissioners who came before them -- already acknowledges the dangers of trotlines in moving water and appealing to them to amend this regulation so that bank-to-bank trotlines across a navigable waterway will no longer be legal.


You can watch our testimony here. The section of the meeting where we appeared begins at the 37:30 mark and lasts for less than 15 minutes.  TFWC Meeting 102221


Following our testimony, the Chairman directed Commissioner Tommy Woods of  Piney Flats, TN, who chairs the Boating and Law Enforcement Committee, and Commissioner Kent Woods of Kodak, TN, who chairs the Fisheries Committee, to work together to gather recommendations for changes to the trotline regulation. After the meeting Director Wilson suggested that I can follow up directly with Fisheries Chief Frank Fiss and Colonel Darren Rider, who serves over Boating and Law Enforcement, to track the progress of this initiative.  We were not given a timeline for next steps, but whatever recommendations are made will have to come to a vote before the full Commission. The next Commission meeting is scheduled for December 16 and 17 in Gatlinburg, TN.

Send Email To TFWC Commissioners Woods And Woods, Chief Fiss And Colonel Rider Donate To The Legal Fund To Defend Scott Fisher And Lobby For Trotline Regulation Change In TN
A man with a backpack is standing on top of a mountain overlooking a lake.

Survival 101: 5 Ways to Stay Out of Trouble in the Outdoors

By Scott Fisher • February 11, 2025
NOLI Survival Instructor Scott Fisher discusses common causes of survival situations and ways to avoid them.
A row of kayaks are lined up on a sandy beach

Hooked on Kayak Camping

By NOLI Instructor Deb Briscoe • July 2, 2024
Anyone who knows me knows how much I love kayak camping.
A group of men are helping a person on a stretcher in the woods.

Wilderness First Responders: Do the Best You Can, with What You Have, Based on What You Know

By Randy Manuel with Scott Fisher • June 12, 2024
NOLI Wilderness First Responder Instructor Randy Manuel makes the case for why those who spend time outdoors should want this training.
A woman with a backpack and hiking poles is standing on top of a grassy hill.

Why I Hike.

By Michelle Duffourc • April 25, 2024
NOLI instructor Michelle Duffourc shares some thoughts on why hiking and backpacking are so special and how they have shaped her life. There's more to it than you might think.
Adam's tips for injury recovery.

Adam's Tips for Injury Recovery

December 14, 2023
On the one year anniversary of his near-fatal accident, NOLI Kayak Instructor Adam Herzog shares tips for recovery.
A river surrounded by rocks and trees on a cloudy day

Dealing with Drought

By Adam Herzog • November 28, 2023
NOLI Kayak Instructor Adam Herzog shares a few thoughts on how to handle the word that paddlers hate most: Drought
A person in a kayak is going down a waterfall.

Pro Tips for Green Race Spectators

By Adam Herzog • October 30, 2023
Veteran racer Adam Herzog shares ways to beat the crowds at one of whitewater's greatest spectacles.
A man is sitting in a yellow kayak in a river holding a paddle.

NOLI Instructor Suffers Near-Fatal Fall and Comes Away with Important Lessons

By Adam Herzog and Scott Fisher • August 16, 2023
The following report was originally published by the American Alpine Club in January 2023 .
A person is paddling a red kayak down a river.

The Joys of Whitewater Kayaking

By Brad Eldridge • July 12, 2023
What makes whitewater kayaking such a blast? Read on to find out.
A group of people are paddling kayaks on a lake.

Kayak Safety & Rescue: Life Lessons in Haro Strait

By Rob Schoborg • June 28, 2023
It was a nearly perfect morning on the Washington state Pacific coast. My wife (Michelle) and I had a delicious breakfast, broke down camp, loaded our rented tandem kayak, and paddled down the sheltered bay that bisects Stewart Island. Along with our guide, Annie, we ran with the tide and a light southwesterly breeze to make the three-mile open water crossing to Henry Island. As we crossed in the 2-foot swells, we were just cruising, enjoying the warmth of the sun, and gazing toward the horizon hoping for our first orca sighting of the trip. Once we passed west of the tip of Henry Island, we headed south a bit and our guide signaled that we would take a break in a field of bull kelp. Thickets of bull kelp make an ideal resting place for sea kayakers because the kelp floats, which are round and 3 to 8 inches across, protrude from the water and break up the momentum of the waves. We stopped for a few minutes, bobbing up and down with the swell, occasionally chatting but mostly taking sips from our water bottles. Over the sound of waves and calling birds, Michelle heard a distant noise. It sounded like a cry for help – or was it a gull? We listened for a few seconds when another, more distinct yell rang out. For an instant we all hesitated, trying to determine the direction of the cries. From our vantage point low to the water, all we could see was dark bull kelp floats scattered across the ocean’s surface. It sounded like the panicked calls were coming from somewhere between us and the shoreline, so we sprinted southeast through the kelp patch toward shore. After we broke through the offshore kelp forest, we spotted two small dark objects on the surface alongside something that looked like a partially submerged log. As the distance closed, the larger object resolved into a flooded green aluminum canoe. The smaller ones were two middle school age boys struggling to reenter the water-filled boat. Every time they tried to enter; the boat would flip. As we neared, they quit trying to enter their boat. Instead, they hung onto the hull of the now inverted canoe and stared quietly as we approached. Michelle and I coasted up on the right side, leaving about a 5-foot gap between our tandem and the canoe, just in case the boys panicked and tried to climb on the deck of our boat before we were prepared. Caution is necessary in a situation like this because a panicking victim can easily capsize a would-be rescuer’s boat - leaving more people in the water. Annie coasted up a similar distance on the left side of the flooded craft. Our first evaluation was that the boys had been in the water for at least fifteen minutes. They were shivering, minimally responsive, and their movements were clumsy. After quickly weighing the options and their condition, we agreed that we could get them out of the water and warm them up more quickly by towing them to shore than by attempting to get the boys back into their boat. We then instructed the closest victim to grab the left perimeter line behind the rear cockpit of our tandem. At first, he refused because he did not want to release the cell phone in his right hand. The impasse was broken when Annie slid her boat up on his left side and convinced him to hand the phone to her. The other boy was similarly coaxed to grab the left stern perimeter line of Annie’s boat. We then started toward shore in the direction of the nearest cottage. When we had closed to within 75 yards of the house, a man came out onto the shore, saw us towing the boys, launched a tandem sit on top kayak, and headed out toward us. The boys, who were shaking with cold, were handed life vests and then hauled aboard the sit on top kayak by their father, while we stabilized the boat. As the reunited family headed back toward shore, we recovered the flooded canoe and towed it to shore. After this brief but adrenaline-filled detour, we continued our journey southwards down the Haro Straight, skirting the shore of Henry Island.
More Posts
Share by: